In the FNAF universe, we have over 161 characters, with some of them making minimal appearances in minigames or main plot titles. These eight characters are only a sliver of what the series has brought over the years, but these, in particular, sparked a curiosity based on the lore behind them.

1. Daycare Attendant (Sun & Moon)

Sporting a jester-like outfit and Split personalities, haunting laughs, and total tonal whiplash, Sun and Moon are standout creations from Security Breach. A game focused on them could experiment with dual gameplay styles: light-hearted puzzle-solving by day, survival horror by night. The potential for fear and fun is sky-high. There hasn’t been a character as complex as Sun & Moon, which is a surprising thing to say, considering the intricacies of the FNAF universe.

2. Stitchwraith

One of the creepiest figures from the Fazbear Frights stories, having only been seen as an Easter egg in Five Nights at Freddy’s: Into the Pit, this animatronic was brought to life by Dr Phineas Taggart in the Fazbear Frights epilogue titled Stitchwraith Stingers. Stitchwraith is a fusion of haunted tech and fractured souls. A dark investigative thriller starring this silent hunter could mix FNAF’s creepy atmosphere with the intrigue of a ghost story—perfect for players who love digging into lore.

3. The Puppet (Marionette)

If there is one character that made me jump out of my skin during my Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 playthroughs, it’s the Puppet. More than just a jumpscare, the Puppet is a tragic protector and one of the few animatronics with a sense of justice. A narrative-driven prequel could place us inside the Puppet’s origin, revealing the events that led to its role in FNAF 2, including the infamous Bite of ’87.

4. Funtime Freddy

Playing an antagonist isn’t something that is typically done in the Five Nights at Freddy’s universe, but we could technically say that Sister Location felt like the night manager was the bad guy. Unhinged, talkative, and totally unpredictable, Funtime Freddy would shine in a psychological horror game where you play as the villain—or something close to it. Imagine being inside the mind of an animatronic built to entertain… but broken beyond repair.

5. Lemonade Clown

This forgotten mascot is pure nightmare fuel. Found in Pizzeria Simulator and Help Wanted 2, Lemonade Clown’s unsettling stillness and ambiguous purpose make him perfect for a slow-burn horror experience. A spin-off featuring vendor bots with dark secrets? Sign us up.

6. Shadow Bonnie

A glitch in the fabric of the FNAF world, Shadow Bonnie is a symbol of corrupted code and twisted memories. A game based on this character could lean into analog horror, blurring the lines between in-game reality and the player’s world. Think FNAF meets Doki Doki Literature Club.

7. RWQFSFASXC (Shadow Freddy)

An echo of something sinister, Shadow Freddy lurks in the background of many games without ever taking center stage. A game exploring the origin of these shadow animatronics could reveal a hidden layer of the FNAF timeline, plunging players into an existential mystery about the very nature of Fazbear’s legacy.

8. M.X.E.S. (from Security Breach: Ruin)

Though only recently introduced, M.X.E.S. is the definition of modern FNAF terror—digital, cryptic, and clearly important. A spin-off game where you battle or escape from this advanced security system gone rogue would push FNAF further into cyber-horror territory, blending old-school tension with high-tech fear.

This unhinged animatronic’s charisma and volatility would make for an unpredictable experience. Let players see through his twisted optics and turn torment into an artform. Playing the villain never sounded so disturbing—or so fun.

Final Thought

The FNAF world is crawling with characters who deserve more than a background cameo. From split-personality daycare attendants to corrupted shadows of the past, these animatronics are ready to rise from the depths of the lore and take center stage. With the fanbase growing and lore expanding, now’s the perfect time to let them loose. For more gaming gear recommendations, check out Total Apex Gaming!