MLB The Show 25 is finally here! The annual release of the series brings new excitement for baseball and sports gaming fans. One of the most popular modes in the game is the Road to the Show. For years, players have loved creating their own personas and climbing the ranks of the minor leagues. How soon a player can get called up to the major leagues depends on your player’s position and the team that drafts you. Getting drafted by a team that is stacked at your position could mean a long slog in the minors. Here are the best teams to get drafted by as a catcher.
MLB The Show 25: Best Teams For A Catcher
Let’s start with a caveat. You have to be good in the minor leagues. It doesn’t matter what position you play if you swing at bad pitches, miss your spots, or make boneheaded baserunning errors. This list is meant to look at where there is the most opportunity to get to the majors as quickly as possible based on the projected Opening Day starter. However, it is also meant to showcase some unexpected teams for each position and ones that could be competing for the World Series soon. The Miami Marlins are great, but you probably aren’t winning many championships in the near future. Onto the list!
Atlanta Braves
Projected Starter: Drake Baldwin 68 Overall in MLB The Show 25
The Atlanta Braves boast one of the most potent hitting lineups in the major leagues. Led by Ronald Acuna Jr., this team has plenty of players who can drive in runs. Jurickson Profar, Matt Olson, and Marcell Ozuna make the top of this lineup one of the best in the majors. Baldwin is the projected Opening Day starter, making this his first year in the major leagues. In real life, I hope Baldwin has an amazing season for Atlanta. In MLB The Show 25 he is an easy target to take down for your player.
This is one to watch throughout the season. Games like MLB The Show 25 often update their player ratings depending on how they do in real life. If Baldwin starts off the season hot, this stop could become more complicated. Regardless, you aren’t competing with a player who has had the position locked down for years. Plus, the Braves are competing for a World Series now, making them an attractive option.
Chicago Cubs
Projected Starter: Miguel Amaya 70 Overall in MLB The Show 25
Speaking of younger players, Amaya is the third-year pro in 2025 and has shown decent potential. His batting average hasn’t eclipsed .250 in his first two years, putting him at the bottom of the hitting order. The top of the order for the Cubs has some solid players, and the NL Central isn’t a powerhouse division.
Taking down a 70 overall player in MLB The Show 25 isn’t a tall task. Overall, this lineup is looking for some pop. If you can craft a power-hitting catcher, the organization could look to bring you up quickly. If you can help lead the Cubs to an NL Central crown, anything can happen in the playoffs.
San Francisco Giants
Projected Starter: Patrick Bailey 76 Overall in MLB The Show 25
The Giants are an interesting team. For years, they have been the standard of excellence but have struggled to get back into contention in the past few seasons. They spent big this offseason, bringing in former Brewers shortstop Willy Adames, and also have a solid rotation. While this isn’t the most powerful team in MLB The Show 25, it is ripe with opportunity.
San Francisco needs some pop in the lineup. Bailey only hit .234 last year and struck out 100 times in 448 plate appearances. They are likely desperate for an upgrade in the position. If you can show off your skills in the minors, it might be a quick call-up to a team that needs players who can drive in runs, especially with the Dodgers in the division.
Final Thoughts
MLB The Show 25 made some awesome improvements to Road to the Show this year. Adding in college teams adds another layer of realism to the game. Are you ready to become the next great catcher? Getting drafted by the right team is essential to your success. Make your choice carefully to maximize your legacy!
