MLB The Show 25: Best Teams To Join As A Starting Pitcher

MLB The Show 25 Road to the Show best teams to join as a starting pitcher

MLB The Show 25 is finally here! The annual release of the series brings new excitement for baseball and sports gaming fans. One of the most popular modes in the game is the Road to the Show. For years, players have loved creating their own personas and climbing the ranks of the minor leagues. How soon a player can get called up to the major leagues depends on your player’s position and the team that drafts you. Getting drafted by a team that is stacked at your position could mean a long slog in the minors. Here are the best teams to get drafted by as a starting pitcher.

MLB The Show 25: Best Teams For A Starting Pitcher

MLB The Show 25
Image from MLB The Show 25 courtesy of Sony Interactive Entertainment

Let’s start with a caveat. You have to be good in the minor leagues. It doesn’t matter what position you play if you swing at bad pitches, miss your spots, or make boneheaded baserunning errors. This list is meant to look at where there is the most opportunity to get to the majors as quickly as possible based on the projected Opening Day starter.

However, it is also meant to showcase some unexpected teams for each position and ones that could be competing for the World Series soon. The Athletics are great, but you probably won’t be winning many championships in the near future. Unlike position players in MLB The Show 25, it is easier to break into a rotation as you only have to beat out the fourth or fifth guy. Onto the list!

New York Mets

Projected Starter: Manuel Margot 69 Overall in MLB The Show 25

1. Clay Holmes, RHP
2. Tylor Megill, RHP
3. Griffin Canning, RHP
4. David Peterson, LHP
5. Kodai Senga, RHP

The Mets are also dealing with injuries that are affecting their Opening Day rotation, but this is a team built on the powerful hitting lineup. Juan Soto was the biggest free-agent prize, and they have plenty of others that can mash the ball. This is good news for you in Road to the Show. A lack of run support is frustrating for any pitcher. You should get plenty of support from this lineup. Furthermore, your player could easily become the ace of this team very soon.

Baltimore Orioles

Opening Day Pitching Rotation

1. Zach Eflin, RHP
2. Charlie Morton, RHP
3. Dean Kremer, RHP
4. Tomoyuki Sugano, RHP
5. Cade Povich, LHP

Baltimore has one of the most fun hitting lineups in the league. Gunnar Henderson, Adley Rutschman, plus many others make this lineup difficult to get through. However, their pitching staff could use some juice. Last year, they traded for Corbin Burnes, but he left in free agency, which was a huge loss. The former Cy Young winner was the clear number one on the staff, and now they are left with a bunch of solid starters. While this can work, an ace is usually needed in the postseason.

In MLB The Show 25, this is the type of lineup you can easily break into in Road to the Show. The good news is that when you are in the majors, the lineup will help give you some run support, putting less pressure on you to have to shut out the best lineups in the game. This isn’t the only AL East team that is a good one to join in MLB The Show 25.

New York Yankees

Opening Day Pitching Rotation:

1. Carlos Rodón, LHP (Gerritt Cole is starting the season on the IL)
2. Max Fried, LHP
3. Marcus Stroman, RHP
4. Will Warren, RHP
5. Carlos Carrasco, RHP

While Cole isn’t injured in the game, the rest of the pitching staff leaves a lot to be desired. Luis Gil is also in the rotation, but that shouldn’t concern you as a player in Road to the Show. If you are trying to get to the majors, you don’t have to be better than the top of the rotation; you just have to be better than the fifth starter. The challenge of joining the Yankees is that you are not in a pitcher-friendly ballpark. However, with Aaron Judge in the lineup, you’ll get plenty of run support.

Final Thoughts

MLB The Show 25 made some awesome improvements to Road to the Show this year. Adding in college teams adds another layer of realism to the game. Are you ready to become the next great right fielder? Getting drafted by the right team is essential to your success. Make your choice carefully to maximize your legacy!

Scroll to Top